by jeSteR » Thu Dec 01, 2011 2:13 pm
Unless it's high end or super unique jewellery, you're going to get shafted anywhere you go. The used market (apart form estate sales) is pretty set in its mark up.
If you have a gold bracelet or diamond that Insurance valuates at say $5000, then the actual street / retail price would probably be around $3000 for the item brand new. If you are trying to sell it on the open market as used, you could be looking at getting around $1300 - $1700 on Craigslist or wherever. Now if you sell to a "broker" "pawn shop" "reseller"... whatever, they will only be able to sell it at the market value as well, and they look to make at least 50 points on their resale, so don't expect much more than $600 - $800 for said item.
You will get hosed.
Just as a frame of reference, I purchased Coleen's Tiffany's Aquamarine Victoria ring through an estate sale. As a Limited Tiffany's product, (not all those mass produced sterling silver charms and tags and crap that you see everywhere) it actually holds it's resale value way better than non branded jewellery
Brand new it was $13000. It's Tiffany's so there is no discount. The seller wanted $8000 for it. I ended up paying $4200.
Don't expect a lot coming back.