by geForce » Mon Oct 17, 2011 8:29 am
I think in this day and age, if you DON'T know that a majority of our North American consumer products are made in China and you haven't seen all the various different sweat shop manufacturing lines and brutal working conditions there, then you'd have to be pretty sheltered or sorry to say it, but you'd be pretty ignorant. We've been bombarded with news about this type of thing way back when Nike, the first major name brand to be outed for using sweat shops in China to make their shoes and clothes back in the 1980's. There's been no shortage of brand names using Chinese labour since then either. The working conditions may have improved since the 80's, but not by much. Also, it's not like the "Made in China" sticker is hidden on all the products we buy.
Is this the failure of a manufacturer? Or is this a failure of China? Or is this a failure at all?
If you look at it this way - if North America pulled all manufacturing out of China, or never started using Chinese labour to begin with, then where would China be today?
Would you rather have millions of Chinese people struggling to survive and scrouning for food? Or would you rather have Chinese people making money working, albeit in crappy conditions, but at least able to buy food and get some sort of shelter?
I'm not excusing myself for not caring about these types of atrocities, but such is the world we live in today. Cause and effect. If it's not one thing, it's another. The person doing this awareness campaign might be trying to fix one type of suffering, but you don't know if the results of those actions will improve things, or just make them worse in a different way.
I remember reading a story back when I was in school in one of my marketing classes about Nestle. They manufacture this powdered baby formula and was donating to Africa. They wanted to help starving African families feed their babies, and their intentions were completely honourable. However, so many babies were getting sick and dying and they found out later that it was because the African moms were using dirty, bacteria-filled water to mix the powdered baby formula with... an example of noble intentions without considering the bigger picture.